NEW: iPhone 18 Pro & Pro Max Cases

Unsolved Mugs

1000+ items

1000+ items

Buy any 2 and get 15% off.Buy any 4 and get 20% off.

Item preview, Cool DB Cooper designed and sold by crenaviolena.

Cool DB Cooper Tall Mug

Item preview, Lizzie Borden Mystery Lizzie Borden 1892 designed and sold by Midnight Kadama Studio.

Lizzie Borden Mystery Lizzie Borden 1892 Classic Mug

Midnight Kadama Studio

Item preview, Chibi Lizzie Borden 1892 designed and sold by Midnight Kadama Studio.

Chibi Lizzie Borden 1892 Classic Mug

Midnight Kadama Studio

Item preview, Miami Midnight designed and sold by HQ74.

Miami Midnight Classic Mug

Item preview, A Secret Remains Unsolved designed and sold by fquikaka.

A Secret Remains Unsolved Classic Mug

Item preview, Knock Knock Lizzie Borden designed and sold by TeeCodes.

Knock Knock Lizzie Borden Tall Mug

Item preview, They Observe designed and sold by CleanLine Studio.

They Observe Classic Mug

CleanLine Studio

Item preview, Unsolved-Mysteries designed and sold by COILLIAMS.

Unsolved-Mysteries Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Lake Camp Incident 1984 Spooky Summer Tape designed and sold by BlkFelineThrds.

Unsolved Lake Camp Incident 1984 Spooky Summer Tape Classic Mug

Item preview, Caffeine and Case Files Retro Design designed and sold by Margaret-Made.

Caffeine and Case Files Retro Design Classic Mug

Item preview, The Mentalist designed and sold by NF Designs Studio DTF.

The Mentalist Classic Mug

NF Designs Studio DTF

Item preview, One more episode. One more crime designed and sold by loobsart.

One more episode. One more crime Classic Mug

Item preview, Perhaps You May Be Able Unsolved Mysteries Television Show designed and sold by RyanThoams.

Perhaps You May Be Able Unsolved Mysteries Television Show Classic Mug

Item preview, Life Unsolved Sticker | Existential Dread & Adulting Meme designed and sold by MyxaART.

Life Unsolved Sticker | Existential Dread & Adulting Meme Tall Mug

Item preview, Coral Castle — One Man. No Cranes. designed and sold by Lucid History.

Coral Castle — One Man. No Cranes. Classic Mug

Item preview, D.B. Cooper - Most Wanted designed and sold by K0tK0tu.

D.B. Cooper - Most Wanted Classic Mug

Item preview, Dangerous Cat designed and sold by SyTcreations.

Dangerous Cat Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved & Unbothered | True Crime Goth Skeleton Coffin Art designed and sold by DmaarGroup.

Unsolved & Unbothered | True Crime Goth Skeleton Coffin Art Classic Mug

Item preview, Ghost Files designed and sold by VernettaShipley.

Ghost Files Classic Mug

VernettaShipley

Item preview, Retro Unsolved Mystery Skull - 80s Synthwave Aesthetic designed and sold by MiPa78.

Retro Unsolved Mystery Skull - 80s Synthwave Aesthetic Tall Mug

Item preview, Man In Suit Standing In Foggy Dark Background designed and sold by ArtofThep.

Man In Suit Standing In Foggy Dark Background Classic Mug

Item preview, Gary Sudbrink Mug designed and sold by MarsBase.

Gary Sudbrink Mug Classic Mug

Item preview, Mike Soup, Dr Goondis, and the Minestrone designed and sold by transgoondis.

Mike Soup, Dr Goondis, and the Minestrone Tall Mug

Item preview, Mike Soup and Dr Goondis designed and sold by transgoondis.

Mike Soup and Dr Goondis Classic Mug

Item preview, Folie à Deux designed and sold by JP Infinity.

Folie à Deux Classic Mug

Item preview, Distressed Mechanical Engineer Unsolved Systems Diagram Design designed and sold by Enea Kelo.

Distressed Mechanical Engineer Unsolved Systems Diagram Design Classic Mug

Item preview, Cryptic Investigation Program designed and sold by plimenitbelters.

Cryptic Investigation Program Classic Mug

plimenitbelters

Item preview, Returned To Sender – Recipient Not Found Mystery Design designed and sold by UnglaublichGut.

Returned To Sender – Recipient Not Found Mystery Design Classic Mug

Item preview, Evidence #42 – Do Not Open Mystery Archive Design designed and sold by UnglaublichGut.

Evidence #42 – Do Not Open Mystery Archive Design Classic Mug

Item preview, The Last Photograph – Black Archive Mystery Design designed and sold by UnglaublichGut.

The Last Photograph – Black Archive Mystery Design Classic Mug

Item preview, Irene Adler Unsolved Case File Sherlock Holmes Gothic Art designed and sold by Fenay Designs.

Irene Adler Unsolved Case File Sherlock Holmes Gothic Art Classic Mug

Item preview, Fermat designed and sold by DFA.

Fermat Classic Mug

Item preview, Flight 19 - Never Forget Chicken Shoals designed and sold by UnZChannel.

Flight 19 - Never Forget Chicken Shoals Classic Mug

Item preview, I Still Don’t Know What Came First, the Chicken or the Egg designed and sold by Supergrafix07.

I Still Don’t Know What Came First, the Chicken or the Egg Classic Mug

Item preview, Emotionally Unsolved Skeleton Detective – Dark Humor Gothic Cyberpunk Art designed and sold by Ecocrushstudio.

Emotionally Unsolved Skeleton Detective – Dark Humor Gothic Cyberpunk Art Classic Mug

Item preview, D.B. Cooper Flight 305 Vintage Mystery Ticket designed and sold by Amnesia-Proto.

D.B. Cooper Flight 305 Vintage Mystery Ticket Tall Mug

Item preview, Janes Does designed and sold by RazaArts12.

Janes Does Classic Mug

Item preview, Mothman Saw Me First Point Pleasant 1966 Vintage Cryptid Paranormal Gift True Crime designed and sold by Amnesia-Proto.

Mothman Saw Me First Point Pleasant 1966 Vintage Cryptid Paranormal Gift True Crime Classic Mug

Item preview, The Black Dahlia Los Angeles 1947 Vintage Noir True Crime Film Noir Art Deco Gift designed and sold by Amnesia-Proto.

The Black Dahlia Los Angeles 1947 Vintage Noir True Crime Film Noir Art Deco Gift Classic Mug

Item preview, Cold Case Coffee Club Est 1947 Vintage True Crime Detective Aesthetic designed and sold by Amnesia-Proto.

Cold Case Coffee Club Est 1947 Vintage True Crime Detective Aesthetic Tall Mug

Item preview, Ryan Solo Investigation designed and sold by Trombonehead42.

Ryan Solo Investigation Tall Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Murders & Root Rot designed and sold by Teeflex.

Unsolved Murders & Root Rot Classic Mug

Item preview, Mothman Warning Sign designed and sold by PopBubbleShop.

Mothman Warning Sign Classic Mug

Item preview, True Crime Expert designed and sold by GhostlyWorld.

True Crime Expert Classic Mug

Item preview, Mothman Beads designed and sold by PopBubbleShop.

Mothman Beads Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack designed and sold by Not-Ciubo.

Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack Classic Mug

Item preview, True Crimes Podcasts designed and sold by NegativeCar.

True Crimes Podcasts Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved: My Missing Socks designed and sold by SparkVault.

Unsolved: My Missing Socks Classic Mug

Unsolved Mysteries Logo Classic Mug

Item preview, unsolved mysteries designed and sold by furnokdorn.

unsolved mysteries Classic Mug

Item preview, Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Funny Nostalgic Quote designed and sold by mjohnson9.

Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Funny Nostalgic Quote Classic Mug

Item preview, Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Nostalgic Saying Quote designed and sold by GreggRoss.

Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Nostalgic Saying Quote Classic Mug

Item preview, Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Funny Nostalgic Quote designed and sold by mjohnson9.

Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Funny Nostalgic Quote Tall Mug

Item preview, Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM designed and sold by KristineLi.

Do You Know The Muffin Man DYKTMM Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack designed and sold by lucky--clover.

Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack Classic Mug

Item preview, I love true crime designed and sold by Shortnotsweet.

I love true crime Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack designed and sold by AgatheLaroc.

Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack Tall Mug

Item preview, Fueled by Coffee and Unsolved Mysteries, Funny Caffeine Item designed and sold by Mogale-Hill.

Fueled by Coffee and Unsolved Mysteries, Funny Caffeine Item Tall Mug

Item preview, Fueled by Coffee and Unsolved Mysteries, Funny Caffeine Item designed and sold by Mogale-Hill.

Fueled by Coffee and Unsolved Mysteries, Funny Caffeine Item Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack designed and sold by BLACK PINK.

Unsolved Mysteries Robert Stack Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack designed and sold by BLACK PINK.

Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries Retro designed and sold by BLACK PINK.

Unsolved Mysteries Retro Classic Mug

Item preview, No Such Unsolved Mysteries Television Show designed and sold by Merchbyzx.

No Such Unsolved Mysteries Television Show Tall Mug

78 Unsolved Mysteries Logo Classic Mug

Item preview, Detective Mollu (Case Unsolved) designed and sold by Hwarang Art.

Detective Mollu (Case Unsolved) Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries designed and sold by Meryemn.

Unsolved Mysteries Classic Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack designed and sold by KirchiStore.

Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack Tall Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack designed and sold by cytheriancrow.

Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack Tall Mug

Item preview, Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack designed and sold by Dope-shirts11.

Unsolved Mysteries - Robert Stack Tall Mug

Item preview, Snowasis Christmas Jumper - Some Might Sleigh designed and sold by mocazaki.

Snowasis Christmas Jumper - Some Might Sleigh Tall Mug

Item preview, Abyss Bottom Horror designed and sold by Midnight Replay.

Abyss Bottom Horror Tall Mug

Midnight Replay

Item preview, Anime Mystery Tier List designed and sold by Midnight Replay.

Anime Mystery Tier List Classic Mug

Midnight Replay

Item preview, Frenchie DB Cooper Mystery designed and sold by Midnight Replay.

Frenchie DB Cooper Mystery Tall Mug

Midnight Replay

Item preview, Frenchie DB Cooper Mystery designed and sold by Midnight Replay.

Frenchie DB Cooper Mystery Tall Mug

Midnight Replay

Item preview, Shiba Bermuda Triangle Puzzle designed and sold by Midnight Replay.

Shiba Bermuda Triangle Puzzle Tall Mug

Midnight Replay

Ghost Files Logo Classic Mug

Item preview, The Real Detective Is Purring Funny Cat True Crime Cold Case Gift designed and sold by LoliDesignShop.

The Real Detective Is Purring Funny Cat True Crime Cold Case Gift Classic Mug

Item preview, Local Legend / Global Nobody - 90s Sticker Bomb Aesthetic designed and sold by FUIRY .

Local Legend / Global Nobody - 90s Sticker Bomb Aesthetic Classic Mug

Item preview, Local Legend Global Nobody - 90s Sticker Bomb Aesthetic designed and sold by FUIRY .

Local Legend Global Nobody - 90s Sticker Bomb Aesthetic Classic Mug

Item preview, True Crime Chronicles designed and sold by Hen-C-Art.

True Crime Chronicles Classic Mug

Item preview, The Dyatlov Pass Mystery – Fragmented Puzzle Piece Art designed and sold by TMD167207.

The Dyatlov Pass Mystery – Fragmented Puzzle Piece Art Tall Mug

Item preview, The Dyatlov Pass Mystery – Jigsaw Puzzle Piece Art designed and sold by TMD167207.

The Dyatlov Pass Mystery – Jigsaw Puzzle Piece Art Tall Mug

Become a member.Get 25% off your first order.Plus other neat perks and exclusive savings to help you find the very thing.

Buzzfeed Unsolved

Worldwide Shipping
Available as standard or express delivery
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Secure Payments
100% Secure Payment with 256-bit SSL encryption
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Free Return
Exchange or money back guarantee for all orders
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Local Support
24/7 Dedicated support
Learn more- opens in new window or tab