Unsettling Pillows & Cushions

1000+ items

The Unsettling Jester Throw Pillow

SparklesMakesStudio

$16.79

~~$22.38~~ (25% off)

"Face in the Dark" یا "Shadowed Portrait" Throw Pillow

SoHighD

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Bound by Silence Throw Pillow

RadManDesigns

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Intense Screaming Portrait Poster Layout Throw Pillow

stoneandslingg

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Funny Vintage Unsettling Images Spooky Pop Art Throw Pillow

DuckOddity

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Creepy Clown Smile - Horror Face Design Throw Pillow

RAYBIL

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Creepy Cute Clown Portrait – Spooky Dark Character Art Throw Pillow

QQQueen

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Creepy Cute One Eyed Creature – Spooky Cute Art with Weird Smile Character Throw Pillow

QQQueen

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Fractured Mindscape – Lightning Storm and Silhouette Throw Pillow

LujziWorld

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Pachymort Throw Pillow

AppliedArcana

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

The Doll Collector Throw Pillow

AppliedArcana

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Charlote the Doll Collected Throw Pillow

AppliedArcana

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

New Weird Fiction Throw Pillow

HRSCreates

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Have a Day. Throw Pillow

Ted Babcock

$16.79

~~$22.38~~ (25% off)

Vintage Horror Mire Encounter Throw Pillow

HumorInHues

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

THE TWISTED CIRCUS – Haunted Carnival Nightmare Throw Pillow

Shadryx

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

HORROR CIRCUS – Night of the Lost Performers Throw Pillow

Shadryx

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

THE HORROR CIRCUS – Twisted Carnival Concept Art Throw Pillow

Haunting Visionary Seer Graphic Throw Pillow

msolgray

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Creepy Jester And Rabbit Indie Horror Characters Throw Pillow

SeraXYZ

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

SHADOWS OF THE CARNIVAL – Dark Horror Concept Art Throw Pillow

Shadryx

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

My Love Language Is Being Really Unsettling Throw Pillow

Bymariart

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

This World Is Unsettling Possum Shirt – Funny Meme Animal Design for Introverts Throw Pillow

Lichtisign

$18.23

~~$24.31~~ (25% off)

Item preview, Backrooms sticker illustration with eerie yellow hallway wallpaper and empty liminal space background for horror gaming layout and creepypasta graphic decoration designed and sold by littleluckystuf.

Backrooms sticker illustration with eerie yellow hallway wallpaper and empty liminal space background for horror gaming layout and creepypasta graphic decoration Throw Pillow

littleluckystuf

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Beautifully Unsettling Throw Pillow

Lady Lunar Solace

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Creepy Cute Monster Girl Surreal Aesthetic Throw Pillow

calavonaOOP

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Unsettling Void Face | Pop Art Creepy Throw Pillow

Sobari

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Triptych Triad Throw Pillow

RossCollie

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Cute Shoebill Throw Pillow

WrenAndWhimsy

$16.79

~~$22.38~~ (25% off)

The Weight of Their Gaze Throw Pillow

halibutgoatramb

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Crackhead Stone Face Wall Clock Design Throw Pillow

SeriouslyArtistical

$15.58

~~$20.76~~ (25% off)

Crouched Raider Man Throw Pillow

Helgoolia

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Menacing Clown Forcing a Smile Art Throw Pillow

zianaokoeck

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Eye Cube Throw Pillow

AbstractAnom

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

The Last Witness Throw Pillow

DarkFlareArt

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Signal Unstable – Analog Horror VHS Static Retro TV Aesthetic Design Throw Pillow

ImaginedSpace7

$15.62

~~$20.82~~ (25% off)

Shadow in Modern Room Throw Pillow

RAISC

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Girl's Shadow in Colorful Room Throw Pillow

RAISC

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Shadow in the Room Throw Pillow

RAISC

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Unsettling Stripe Pattern Throw Pillow

smh2

$18.98

~~$25.30~~ (25% off)

Shadow Girl Among Roses Throw Pillow

RAISC

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Unsettling Stripes Throw Pillow

smh2

$18.98

~~$25.30~~ (25% off)

Notification There Is Motion At Your Front Door Quandale Dingle Internet Meme Throw Pillow

SanTiOmal

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

The Whispering Man Halloween Horror Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

Melting Porcelain Doll Face | Gothic Haunted Toy Horror Aesthetic Throw Pillow

DmaarGroup

$16.35

~~$21.80~~ (25% off)

Aye-Aye – Unease & Mystery Throw Pillow

WildlifeInc

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Pumpkin Mothgirl Throw Pillow

VineFiddle

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Creepy Abandoned Carnival Watercolor Art with Dark Circus Clown Entrance Throw Pillow

eliramaison

$17.37

~~$23.16~~ (25% off)

Nightmare Throw Pillow

JJESTOICO

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Dark Carnival Clown Watercolor Throw Pillow

eliramaison

$17.37

~~$23.16~~ (25% off)

The Slice She Didn’t Expect Throw Pillow

TreatLLC

$15.33

~~$20.43~~ (25% off)

Framed Android Eyes Baroque Portrait Watching You Throw Pillow

Ghoul Enterprises

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Creepy Big Eye Black Cat Face Throw Pillow

Peac7e

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Ugly flying sheep for your daily dose of surrealism Throw Pillow

LujziWorld

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Green & Pink Ice Cream Heads Throw Pillow

LujziWorld

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

The Dark Room Tarot Card – Childhood Fear Minimal Horror Black & White Art Throw Pillow

MotivAura

$17.37

~~$23.16~~ (25% off)

Dark Humor Vintage Kid Horror – “Let’s Have Some Fun” Retro Creepy Cartoon Throw Pillow

SidTastic

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Floating Fear Minimalist Balloon Throw Pillow

agearb

$17.23

~~$22.96~~ (25% off)

Paranoia, Conspiracy Theorists' Eyes Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

THE ROOM THAT WAITS Throw Pillow

ViralVisionsCreating

$18.39

~~$24.52~~ (25% off)

THE QUIET ISN’T EMPTY Throw Pillow

ViralVisionsCreating

$18.39

~~$24.52~~ (25% off)

THE WALLS KNOW MY NAME Throw Pillow

ViralVisionsCreating

$18.39

~~$24.52~~ (25% off)

SOMETHING WAITS IN THE HALLWAY Throw Pillow

ViralVisionsCreating

$18.39

~~$24.52~~ (25% off)

THE HOUSE IS LISTENING Throw Pillow

ViralVisionsCreating

$18.39

~~$24.52~~ (25% off)

The Unseen Presence: Haunted 1850s Victorian Daguerreotype Throw Pillow

Mystral Art Studio

$17.81

~~$23.74~~ (25% off)

The Chosen Salvation - dark horror illustration Throw Pillow

Mr.Izinto

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Vintage Screen Horror Poster, Crowd and Media Horror Art, Dark Technology Illustration Throw Pillow

Creeping Throw Pillow

Shellie Bruner

$21.90

~~$29.19~~ (25% off)

Creepy AI Doll Horror Aesthetic Dance M3gan Megan Inspired Design Throw Pillow

creatingmouseshop

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

I Have Made It Awkward Japanese Spider Crab Surreal Horror Vintage T-Shirt Throw Pillow

tarzbol

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Christopher Throw Pillow

themusegg

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Carrie Funko Horror Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

Carrie Funko Horror Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

Babadook “Still Here” Sticker Cute Horror Chibi Creepy Art Throw Pillow

CMLPaintings

$18.98

~~$25.30~~ (25% off)

Chucky Funko Horror Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

Creepy Spooky Unsettling Face Throw Pillow

AnandaHadaz

$16.06

~~$21.41~~ (25% off)

Chucky Funko Horror Throw Pillow

NF Designs Studio DTF

$18.79

~~$25.05~~ (25% off)

Copy Creepy AI Doll Horror Aesthetic Dance M3gan Megan Inspired Design Throw Pillow

creatingmouseshop

$17.52

~~$23.35~~ (25% off)

Creepy Smiley Face – Dark Humor Cartoon Grin Throw Pillow

Kruti Collection

$21.17

~~$28.22~~ (25% off)

Sad Clown Doll – Dark Cute Aesthetic Throw Pillow

HeyHas

$18.98

~~$25.30~~ (25% off)

Become a member.Get 25% off your first order.Plus other neat perks and exclusive savings to help you find the very thing.

Home & Living

Pillow

Unsettling

Unsettling artworks printed on 16”, 18”, 20”, 24”, 26”, 36” / 40 cm, 45 cm, 50 cm, 60 cm, 65 cm, 90 cm cushions for your lounge, bedroom, or dorm. The covers have hidden zipper closures, are printed front and back, and are totally washable.