Murder Mystery Caps

1000+ items

Unsolved Mysteries logo Dad Hat

Primotees

$21.32

~~$25.08~~ (15% off)

Clue Logo Baseball Cap

Copy of nay nay i say suspish - bailey sarian quote in black Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Jessica Fletcher Judging #29 Dad Hat

sarahisawitch

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Don't mess with a woman who knows how to stage a crime scene Baseball Cap

AnnaBD

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Dateline a Dateline a Dateline a Dateline Dad Hat

Huffohop

$26.76

~~$31.49~~ (15% off)

Cabot Cove Light house, Population on the decline 1984 Dad Hat

boec gear

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

But here’s what really happened. Dad Hat

AudgePodgeArt

$25.87

~~$30.44~~ (15% off)

Thriller Baseball Cap

Rancy .

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

suspish - bailey sarian quote in black Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Sorry I Can't My Murder Shows Are On Baseball Cap

FantasticBee

$19.81

~~$24.77~~ (20% off)

Murder A to Z Dad Hat

Leah K

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Nordic Noir Scandinavian Murder Mystery Baseball Cap

Huhnerdieb Apparel

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Don't mess with me, I've seen all 406 episodes of Forensic Files Dad Hat

FANG BANG

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Murder cat funny scary Baseball Cap

villainmaz

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Bailey Sarian Suspish Dad Hat

Rainboon

$22.30

~~$26.24~~ (15% off)

bailey sarian suspish Baseball Cap

FunSesame

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Murder Mystery and Makeup - Makeup Girl Dad Hat

Gummy Bear Gift Shop

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

I Love Murder Mysteries Baseball Cap

shitpostee

$21.83

~~$27.29~~ (20% off)

Funny Nagatha Christie Agatha Christie Mystery Nagger Dad Hat

GaffaDesigns

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Suspish- Bailey Sarian Baseball Cap

tasshop

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

I Love Murder Mysteries Baseball Cap

Murder Mystery and Makeup -Anime Girl Baseball Cap

Gummy Bear Gift Shop

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Clue Mrs White Flames Dad Hat

markdwaldron

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Aqua Tofana: For When Life Gets Too Toxic - Dark Humor Self-Care Dad Hat

DesignDazzles

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Marlow Murder Club Group Baseball Cap

BronteDetenbeck

$18.47

~~$23.09~~ (20% off)

Spy / Detective Baseball Cap

glass onion title Dad Hat

sarascoprox

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Shetland Shite Black Dad Hat

Normbot2000

$19.62

~~$23.09~~ (15% off)

Keep Calm and wait for Jessica Fletcher Baseball Cap

Normbot2000

$18.47

~~$23.09~~ (20% off)

Murder Mystery - Mystery Skulls Baseball Cap

Keep Calm and Watch French Murder Mysteries, Mystery Lover Dad Hat

FarmOfCuties

$20.52

~~$24.14~~ (15% off)

Christmas Murder Mystery Dad Hat

Parasocial Pariah

$22.30

~~$26.24~~ (15% off)

Keep Calm and Watch British Murder Mysteries, Mystery Lover Baseball Cap

FarmOfCuties

$19.31

~~$24.14~~ (20% off)

Shetland Shite Baseball Cap

Normbot2000

$18.47

~~$23.09~~ (20% off)

Melody for Murder Clue Mystery Lynn Landis Dad Hat

7SKIES

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Weekend Plans Snacks and Suspects Cosplay Design Dad Hat

Mauswohn

$20.52

~~$24.14~~ (15% off)

Armchair Detective Woman Dad Hat

MatthewCo20362

$26.76

~~$31.49~~ (15% off)

Aqua Tofana Baseball Cap

Keep Calm and wait for DS Healy Dad Hat

Normbot2000

$19.62

~~$23.09~~ (15% off)

Keep Calm and wait for DS Tosh Dad Hat

Normbot2000

$19.62

~~$23.09~~ (15% off)

Midsomer Murders Dad Hat

SparklesMakesStudio

$20.52

~~$24.14~~ (15% off)

You Know That's Right Baseball Cap

Cute gift for British Mystery Show Lover Baseball Cap

GlassAndDagger

$25.19

~~$31.49~~ (20% off)

MURDER MYSTERY Baseball Cap

Pat McNeely

$18.47

~~$23.09~~ (20% off)

Murder Mystery Book Stack Baseball Cap

AaronHoy

$19.31

~~$24.14~~ (20% off)

TALK TO ME ABOUT TRUE CRIME Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

TRUE CRIME OBSESSED Baseball Cap

TrueCrimeDesign

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Murder Mystery Podcast Baseball Cap

SydStot

$29.38

~~$36.73~~ (20% off)

Keep Calm and wait for Charlie Chan Dad Hat

Normbot2000

$19.62

~~$23.09~~ (15% off)

Jessica Fletcher Judging #41 Baseball Cap

sarahisawitch

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Coastal Magic Convention 2026: A Murder In Bloom Dad Hat

Mythic Logic Art

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Jessica Fletcher Judging #45 Dad Hat

sarahisawitch

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Cozy Murder Book Club Dad Hat

stephenflashart

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Jessica Fletcher Judging #38 Dad Hat

sarahisawitch

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Jessica Fletcher Judging #42 Baseball Cap

sarahisawitch

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Mystery message Baseball Cap

Ohayomoumen

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Nordic Noir Binge Watching Skip Intro Baseball Cap

Huhnerdieb Apparel

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Straight Outta River Heights Dad Hat

Normbot2000

$19.62

~~$23.09~~ (15% off)

The Thursday Murder Club Dad Hat

NEKKI Originals

$26.76

~~$31.49~~ (15% off)

Aqua Tofana Bailey Sarian Baseball Cap

TrueCrimeDesign

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

nay nay i say suspish - bailey sarian quote in pink Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Youre in a cult call your dad SSDGM True Crime Podcast Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Aqua Tofana Bailey Sarian Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Youre in a cult call your dad SSDGM MFM True Crime Podcast Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Serial Chiller Bailey Sarian Baseball Cap

TrueCrimeDesign

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Aqua Tofana - Bailey Sarian Baseball Cap

TrueCrimeDesign

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Ask Me About Serial Killers Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Mysteries over Murder Dad Hat

Petthecatshop

$20.52

~~$24.14~~ (15% off)

“MURDER” Baseball Cap

PawsitiveMum3

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Make Good Choices Get Better Idols Suspish Bailey Sarian Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

suspish - bailey sarian quote in pink Dad Hat

TrueCrimeDesign

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Hercule Poirot’s Little Grey Cells Dad Hat

Stippledoo

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

That’s how it could have happened. Dad Hat

AudgePodgeArt

$25.87

~~$30.44~~ (15% off)

Aqua Tofana And Skull With Flowers Baseball Cap

Bailey Sarian Dad Hat

Rainboon

$22.30

~~$26.24~~ (15% off)

Book T-shirt Design Baseball Cap

RoseShop2093

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Ferocious Gear Badger Baseball Cap

funspms

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

DTF St. Louis Let the Sunshine In Dad Hat

WigOutlet

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

It’s All Fun & Games Until Someone Ends Up Dead – The Escape Game Baseball Cap

Scrumptious Designs

$18.47

~~$23.09~~ (20% off)

DTF St. Louis - ASL Down to F*%& St. Louis Dad Hat

WigOutlet

$21.41

~~$25.19~~ (15% off)

Comfy clothes & murder shows Baseball Cap

Eric Luken

$20.15

~~$25.19~~ (20% off)

Mondays Are For Murder Mysteries (Bailey Sarian / True Crime Inspired) Dad Hat

teawithbea

$23.19

~~$27.29~~ (15% off)

Become a member.Get 25% off your first order.Plus other neat perks and exclusive savings to help you find the very thing.

Worldwide Shipping
Available as standard or express delivery
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Secure Payments
100% Secure Payment with 256-bit SSL encryption
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Free Return
Exchange or money back guarantee for all orders
Learn more- opens in new window or tab
Local Support
24/7 Dedicated support
Learn more- opens in new window or tab

Murder Mystery Caps

Worldwide Shipping

Secure Payments

Free Return

Local Support

Shop

About

Help

Social