WanderingAuthor


Art Vs. Commerce

I’ve been thinking a lot about this issue lately. I want to develop what talent I have to its highest potential. To do this, I need to write as much as possible. To do that, I need to be free of the necessity of bringing in cash in ways that don’t develop my writing skills.

At the moment, most writers don’t even make enough to live on. I know of one professional author, published, been writing for over fifteen years. You could walk in a bookstore and find at least a few of her books there. Yet she noted her income last year was in the “high four figures”. I’m not naming her, since I can’t be sure how widely she’d want that detail known. For those of you in other countries, where she lives, “high four figures” is worse than what a dishwasher or janitor makes.

Yet you read everywhere that, on the Internet, “content is king.” We write content, better than most of what’s out there, and we can’t make a living, while there are spammers and scrapers making a hundred thousand and more a month! Yes, that does tick me off! Steal my content, and a few thousand other people’s, and you could make more than I can honestly writing it.

I posted about some of these thoughts on another writing site, one for writers seeking serious careers and publication. I tossed out a few ideas, poorly thought out, just for brainstorming. How can we as writers make more cash, and get at least a little slice of the pie? How can we survive the changes in culture and society? I also raised a lot of issues I know many writers must fear. The result? Some people disagreed. I can live with that. But some people accused me of writing because I want to get rich.

I am not a writer because I think it will make me rich. I’d be happy to make just enough of a living to write and nothing else. Yes, I also wouldn’t mind making a little more than that, if fortunes are going to be made on the foundation of “content”, but that isn’t why I write.

Dickens took whatever writing jobs would pay him. So did a lot of other great writers. They had to eat. So do I. In their day, they made enough that they could do nothing but write, and that time to develop skill and talent is one of the things that made them great.

So I’ve thought of some ideas, ways I might be able to ask a higher price for my writing than it would normally command. I don’t know if they’ll work until I try them. I’m not outlining them here since, as they are my ideas, I’d at least like to clearly be the one to try them out first, before someone else runs off with them. Some of them, honestly, involve asking some pretty high prices, and ‘creating’ a market for the work.

I’ve thought over what terms I’d have to insist on to preserve my freedom to write honestly, as I would in other situations. But I wonder, is there something wrong with trying to make money from creative writing? Does it somehow compromise what we do? I’m not worried about the other end – creative writing is a luxury – if I can figure out a way to ask twenty million (I’m not really thinking anywhere near that…) for a story, and get it, no one had to pay that, so in my opinion, it’s fair enough. I’m just trying to work out if it will somehow make me less of a writer.

Do the rest of you wrestle with issues like this?

  • PJ Ryan

    PJ Ryan

    oh welcome to my mind :)

    Writing is a passion .. a gift (i will speak for myself here) .. and who wouldn’t like to make a career/living from something they are passionate about.

    Chefs are fabulous cooks who delight in cooking and creating with food. I’d like that success as a writer (and then some).

    I don’t have the time to be a prolific writer (as i’d like to).

    I’d truly like to lock myself away in a room and write. They say it’s a lonely life for a serious writer. I can understand why.

    Following creative urges, means that you need to run with them when the urge hits. It doesn’t work as well to jot it down on a paper and come back to it (although of course, sometimes it does work that way because i follow that method at times).

    I’m a mother of 4 children and so my time is incredibly artistic to jungle. I manage to satisfy the creative desire although i’ve put my dreams/wants/passions on hold on and off through my life. To actually make a career from it seems selfish. At what point in my life will i be able to strive for that? It would seem a waste to not pursue that now.

    So slowly i totter on.

    Who knows if it will bring the financial success i dream of.

    Of course, the publication and success – knowing that i am sharing my gift with other people who care to view it means most to me. Money matters too. We all need money.

    To earn the money you’re considering (and i’m talking about) one needs to be churning out extremely successful books/novels/playwright/series OR a successful song or two works well :)

    Ah yes. Struggling artists.

    There is nothing wrong with trying to make money from creative writing.

    Successful and financially swollen creative writers exist throughout our world.

    I’ll race you there :)

    xx

  • DBALehane

    DBALehane

    This is an extremely though provoking post and certainly a very welcome one here on Red Bubble. So thank you for taking the considerable time to write and post it here.

    I saw something in one of the UK writing magazines a few months back that said of all the published authors in the world only 10% actually made a living from their writing alone. That’s quite a sobering thought.

    I’m fortunate in that I have a decent career away from writing that I enjoy and pays the bills. Of course, like any writer, I dream of a day where earnings from my writing allowed me to quit the job (simply so I could concentrate on writing more than I am able at this time). However, my main, most realistic aim, is to earn enough from writing to at least allow me to go part-time in the day (and sometimes night) job.

    However, I write because I am driven to write. I always have been since I was a child. If I wanted to get rich, then there would be other paths I’d traverse instead of writing.

    We have to be pretty thick skinned as writers. We have to be able to take criticism. We have to be able to take rejection. We have to be able to let go of our written “babies” once they are out there in the real world. Not everyone is cut out for this.

    Then to give ourselves a fighting chance as a writer we need to have a basic grasp of writing and the tools of grammar/punctuation. Yes, there may be exceptions to this, but they are rare. On the whole most editors won’t consider anything badly written, spelt or grammatically incorrect, even if the writing is full of heart and passion. I know this view has got me into trouble on here before, but it is a simple fact of a hard writing world.

    As Nicole rightly says, there are successful writers out there, in a financial sense. Virtually all of these write to commenrcial markets and do so well and within the conformity of good grammar.

  • PJ Ryan

    PJ Ryan

    If I wanted to get rich, then there would be other paths I’d traverse instead of writing.

    oh yes, there are easier ways ..

    Writing is about passion. First and foremost that’s why people write .. i think you’ll find most people start writing as an escape, a coping method or for romance (those love poems we wrote when we were young and thought it was truly the love of our lives hahah) ..

    The urge to make $$$ tends to fall into place later .. it really does come down to doing what you enjoy, what your are gifted or trained at .. and what is practical. Hopefully it will be all three things combined.

  • PJ Ryan

    PJ Ryan

    *what you are gifted or trained at

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    Nicole, I agree with you. And Lehane, most of the exceptions you concede are written by those who know the rules, and know when to break them.

    What I’m interested in, though, is taking things a bit farther; as writers, thinking of innovative ways to get paid for our work, to permit more writers to make a living as writers, so they can develop their skill.

    I will write, no matter what. That is not in question. But I’d prefer the chance to go further, and to give that same chance to others. Why should writers produce much of the content the Internet thrives on, while it is the businessmen who prosper from their efforts?

  • deliriousgirl

    deliriousgirl

    I will write, no matter what. That is not in question.

    So will I as will any writer. I’m lucky enough to have a career that I love in a field that has nothing to do with writing. But I know, I know. . .the little niggling thoughts are always there. . .I wonder if I could make it as a writer.

    One of the problems with being paid what your writing is worth is in the simple fact of the twist that the advent of the internet has brought to us all. There is just so much out there for free that most people (the numbers of actual book readers dwindles each year also) just don’t want to pay for it anymore. That and the very difficult and drawn out processes of getting any major or even minor publishing companies behind you makes it nigh on impossible for good writing to ever make it to even a small audience. I’ve done a couple of the small chap books in the past and flogged them to death on sites all over to not much success. I think my kinfolk bought about 25 or so copies.

    The economy is another deterrent to being well paid for writing, when hard times kick in as they have recently here in the US, books and literature are considered luxuries that are the first thing to go out of the old budget.

    Sure, Stephen King is a gazillionaire, but I think I read somewhere that only about 2% of writers in the US can currently make a living writing. And that even applies to newspapers and magazine writing too. I actually tried to make it in the newspaper writing world once and it’s a hand-to-mouth existence despite having to work very long and very irregular hours. And the writing wasn’t really satisfying for me either, it was much too dull and restrictive. Damn, I couldn’t even say fuck or anything!

    So, I have no idea what the answer is. I do know that it is something that all writers think about. Please do let us know if your experiments work out though!

    Jeeeeeeeze, I didn’t mean to re-write War and Peace here!!!! Sorry!

  • deliriousgirl

    deliriousgirl

    By the way, this site and sites like it are great for the community with other like-minded people and great to run short pieces on to gauge reactions ( nobody ever reads the longer ones mostly, been there tried that) and for socializing with amazing, creative people – but I don’t think anybody’s gonna get a book deal or a contract out of it.

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    @deliriousgirl – who said I was going to make the readers pay? If I can find any way to get paid, I don’t care who it is. And I don’t care if I’m a gazillionaire – my goal is simply to have more time to write, so I can develop my writing further.

    I hope I didn’t give anyone the impression I was expecting to get any book deals out of posting here. If it ever happens to anyone, that will be the exception that proves the rule. What some writers might be able to do, if they are lucky, is build up a small readership. The more people you have who want to read you, the more potential for publicity and sales – if you land a book deal. Even then, however, as you correctly note, feedback and the chance to socialize are the only benefits you can count on.

  • deliriousgirl

    deliriousgirl

    Hey, I had a girlfriend who was actually paid for a blog she did. She had a link to click on to a paypal account and a whole lot of people regularly contributed to her because they just loved reading about her life so much. She did get a book deal and a column in Penthouse out of it too.

    It does seem to be the wave of the future.

    And no, I didn’t think that you said that about a book deal or anything. Was just pointing out the things that I like about this site.

    The time thing, I have no idea how to solve, as I too am really really crunched for time and sometimes go for long periods just carrying various ideas around in my head, no real time to sit down and pound them out.

    Hey, we should all be looking for a grant, I know they have them here. Now I’m gonna have to research that, but I remember reading about several well known authors who got their start with grants from Arts organizations. Jacqueline Mitchard was one and I think Joyce Carol Oates did too.

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    Grants are another possibility. I think it is a shame that only 2% of writers in the US can make a living at it. Go into any bookstore, buy a handful of books by American authors, then read them. You may find some junk, but I’m sure you’d find more than 2% whose writing ought to be worth at least a living wage.

    I might not be quite so worked up on this, if I hadn’t read several bragging postings by guys who make $100,000 a month or more – for throwing up spam pages all over the Internet. And scrapers make fortunes, too, stealing other people’s stuff. If jerks like that can rake in that much cash, writers ought to be able to pull in a living wage.

    Yes, I dream about striking it rich, and if I ever did, up to a point, I’d hang onto the money. I’d hang onto enough to build a good house, one with a great place to write. And I’d buy a truckload of fountain pens. And I’d keep enough to live through a few lean times. But you know what? If I made $100,000 a month, I’d unload a lot of it. Why? Because having too much money will eat up your time, just dealing with it. So I’d keep what I needed to make my writing life better, and pour the rest into grants for other writers or something. That way I’d have more time to write.

  • deliriousgirl

    deliriousgirl

    Because having too much money will eat up your time, just dealing with it. So I’d keep what I needed to make my writing life better, and pour the rest into grants for other writers or something.

    Brilliant! Yes, I have a pretty great life now, don’t know that a big bunch of money would change anything, at least right now at the present. Do you actually write with pens and paper these days? Just curious. I do everything from making a grocery list to paying all bills to jotting down ideas to writing sweeping epic historical pieces (99999999999999999999999999 words of crap, in other words) on a computer these days.

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    I do some of my writing on a computer, but I also like to write with pen and paper. First, it lets me write in situations where I have no access to a computer. Second, writing with a Pelikan fountain pen filled with Noodlers ink is, to me, the one method that creates the least barrier between my mind and the paper. (Yes, the brand of ink makes a difference; it writes very smoothly and won’t clog my pen.)

  • deliriousgirl

    deliriousgirl

    HAAAAAAA!!! So funny! I used to be just that way and it took me forever to get used to thinking and typing, for a couple of years I would write it all out on yellow legal pads and a #3 cedar pencil and then had to prop it up secretary style and type it in. I did all my papers for school that way. Now my brain is directly hardwired to the fingertips. And yes, you’re absolutely correct, the tools make a difference.

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    Hi WA
    I have been involved in the underground / d.i.y. music scene for the last 25 years. I have put out my own bands records and other people have put out my bands records; we have toured and gigged as much as our jobs and other commitments would allow; yet I can garentee that there is probably no one here on Red Bubble who will ever have even heard of one of my bands.

    I do it because I enjoy it, I accept that at best I can only break even; but then again the music I play is a niche market within punk hardcore and extreme metal that doesn’t fall neatly into any pigeon holes. If I wanted to make some money out of it I’d really have compromise the type of music I played.

    Writing is the same; Bukowski said that he just kept writing the same stuff all the time, but it took him almost a life time for the rest of the world to catch up with him!

    I’m not sure how you can make money out of it; but if you do find out: please let me know!

    Cheers

    Micky

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    Yes, that is the problem. How to make money without making compromises. What really sets me off is this: authors who keep getting contracts from publishers can’t even make a living. And scrapers and spammers can? You read “Content is King” of the Internet, but money types who use content collect the taxes.

    I’m just hoping we can put our heads together and figure something out. I do this because I love it, and I’ll do it if I never make a penny from it. For years, I’ve ignored that aspect altogether. But suddenly, I realised that I can become a better writer faster if I can do it all the time. If I work out a way, I’ll let you know. :-)

    I’m considering several options. Giving away e-books seems to work for established authors – I wonder if it would help build visibility? (I don’t advise trying that one without thinking over your options very carefully, though.) Whatever marketing avenues the Internet offers, of course, for sales and publicity. And I’m toying with ideas for getting paid to write that will leave me free to write the things I want. The last is the least likely to work, but has the most potential if I can make it work.

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    have a look at this ...

  • WanderingAuthor replied

    All true, no real surprises there. And yet, I’m going to go on trying. I will write, no matter what. And I will do all I can to write full time, since that is the best way to develop.

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    I think that is very courageous; best of luck : O )

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    I don’t know about courage; I don’t really have a choice. I am a writer. No matter what society does or says, that truth won’t change. Thanks for the best wishes, though. Best of luck to you, as well. You’ve got talent enough, if life was “fair”, to make a go of it.

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    Thanks WA. It’s just scary to try and make a living from writing alone.
    Hope the T-shirts take off… I have only sold one of mine… so I’m sure be able to better that ; )

  • WanderingAuthor replied

    Scary, yes, it is. I suspect it would be as scary to try to make a living from music or art. But I’m a writer. Scary or not, I can’t change that. (And, oh, heck, might as well admit how crazy I am – I wouldn’t change it if I could.)

    Well, I’m not expecting to sell truckloads, but perhaps I can build up a little momentum over time. Good luck with yours, and your writing, and your band. By the way, do you have a web site for the band? Have you tried social media marketing?

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    that should be “so I’m sure you’ll be able to better that ; )”

  • Micky McGuinness

    Micky McGuinness

    Hi WA
    Having a young family and a reasonably paid job; I’m never going to be in the position to make money out of the band.
    Also the type of music isn’t in any way commercial:

    If you want to know what we sound like; click this pic

    As for the writing: I live in hope ; )

    Cheers

    Micky

  • WanderingAuthor

    WanderingAuthor

    It does have a certain raw power, though. And I wasn’t thinking you’d make a living at it, but every bit of exposure helps out, doesn’t it? Since a lot of social media marketing is stuff that doesn’t cost anything (and you’re doing some of it already, like having a MySpace page) if you’re ever looking for tips, let me know.

Add your comment

You need to login or signup to add your comment to this work.