Painting or Photographing with Emotion

The following article was written by Robert Genn, a Canadian painter of International repute who runs an art listing site called The Painter Keys..I have permission to reproduce his writings here..
I think the advice can work equally well for photographers as well as painters
..

Yesterday, Dan McGrath of Lexington, Kentucky, wrote, “I consider myself an experienced landscape painter, but I see advice from successful artists: ‘Paint what you feel about a subject, not just what you see.’ As an ex-engineer, I don’t have a clue what I feel about a subject except that I love being outdoors and being in the places I visit. How does one recognize or introduce emotion into a scene? Is it bright colors, strong value contrasts, or what?”
Dan…. Your work shows what I call the “engineer’s touch.” This means your paintings have precise, organized and well-thought-out compositions. Further, you are blessed with good drawing, colour wisdom, aerial perspective and a strong sense of light and shade. Many artists would love to have these abilities. Your work already has the bright colours and strong contrasts you mentioned. Let’s look further
: 


Contrivances, whether conscious or unconscious, are the first place to start looking. Dan’s work, like that of a lot of other painters, often shows a formalized and conservative consistency. In his case, it’s often a stabilizing horizontality or a (generally foreground) lineup that repeats from painting to painting. To get more emotion, you need to forego some of this engineering and let yourself be a bit more of a swinger. 

Further, be careful with static elements, such as rocks. These are not objects to buttress a composition. They are living, breathing, painterly illusions with latent dynamism. While your work shows care and labour, care and labour are not necessarily emotions. 

Apart from the emotion one finds in masterful faces (see Rembrandt’s portraits) and the emotion connected to a sensitive place (see Edward Hopper’s lonely cafés), there’s the tactile emotion that comes out of the end of the brush. Brushwork, energetic and fresh, might be just enough additional emotion for your well-engineered landscapes. In the words of Elbert Hubbard, “Allow motion to equal emotion.” 


Better to be without logic than without feeling.” (Charlotte Bronte)
“I want to draw and study a few things closely by feeling, not thinking
.” (Joanna Field) 



Esoterica: “Consider adding painterly energy and bravura to give a bit more dazzle and authenticity to the work.” I know the old saw is a bit jaded, but think of this one as well: “The main thing is sincerity, and when you learn to fake that, you’ve got it made.”
-----------------

ALSO..BRAND NEW articles posted today at News and Views

If it’s Play, Then You’re Not Serious”..

Want to find out if your paintings or photos have suddenly grown legs and have now walked into someone else’s web site or gallery?..read “AWOL”...

New additional “QUICK TIPS
-----------------
SAMPLES OF PREVIOUS POSTS ...click archive…

Are you jealous of other Artist’s work?

Are you afraid to be yourself?

New Writing posts from 2008 revisited
CONFIDENCE IN YOUR WORK
ART AND HAPPINESS
LOOSEN UP YOUR STYLE OF PAINTING

Great artists, including a blind artist...

  • Hidemi Tada

    Hidemi Tada

    i feel you are posting this article for me, Janis. i always learn something from you. thank you for sharing Janis.

  • Janis Zroback replied

    I’m happy it resonated with you Hidemi…I try to paint with my emotions and forget about so called rules…because I’m self taught, the rules don’t mean much to me…

  • thepaintedsoul

    thepaintedsoul

    This is an interesting article Janis. A good starting point for thinking about how we approach our work. But I think Mr. Genn could have elaborated a bit more to make it more helpful on one aspect of this subject. Would love to have seen him define emotion.
    .................................................................
    My reason for saying this. . .I’ve often read reviews where someone says the painter has a lot of emotion in his pictures. To tell the truth, that doesn’t really help me understand the painter’s work. It leaves me wondering: what is the nature of the emotion the artist puts into his painting. And what does the reviewer mean? Is this artist’s work sad? Happy? Exciting? Sensual? Angry?
    .............................................................
    Chuck Close puts a strong emotion in his work. He’s a photorealist whose work I can’t stand because of the cold, calculated, mundaneness he portrays by his lack of brushwork, his imagery, etc. It doesn’t make his painting bad, but he’s an artist whose work I avoid because of how it affects me. : >D
    ...............................................
    Richard Estes’ work is emotionally cool, but I find it appealing in the same way that I enjoy Bach’s Brandenburg concertos. Theres’ a complexity and sophistication in it that engages my mind.
    .........................................
    Okay, now I’ll get down off of my soapbox. : >D See, that article was a good one. It prompted me to rant. But it was a kind rant. Wasn’t it?
    ........................................
    Thanks for posting Mr. Genn’s article. Have a great weekend! Cheers, TPS

  • Janis Zroback replied

    I could have posted some of the paintings he was talking about, but I don’t have the artist’s permission for that, so I had to leave them out…I think he means forgetting the rules a bit and concentrating on conveying something more…I don’t think he necessarily means looser brush strokes, but maybe a different point of view…I think the emotion could be any or all the things you mention, plus your reaction to it…it should be more than just a replica of the place or face…

    Re Chuck Close.. undoubtedly it’s there…very raw…all his portraits seem to be angry…

    In the end I think he is saying the artist should put something more into his work than a record of what is there, just beautifully painted…then it’s up to the viewer whether they respond positively or otherwise to the work…

  • Janis Zroback replied

    P.S. rant away as long as I am not the subject of it.. :))

  • FlowersEtc

    FlowersEtc

    Wonderful, thanks

  • Janis Zroback replied

    Thank you so much Ann.. :))

  • thepaintedsoul

    thepaintedsoul

    You are such a kind friend, Janis. Thanks!

  • Janis Zroback replied

    You’re very welcome….. :))

  • Isa Rodriguez

    Isa Rodriguez

    fabulous writing , so inspirational. yes, Janis, we sure do learn from you with your helpful artist

    I think the end places it exactly where it hits me the most

    dont be afraid of being you . allow motion to be emotion..
    thanks , Janis. you are so kind .

  • Janis Zroback replied

    You’re very welcome Isa…I’m glad you found it helpful…

  • Vickyh

    Vickyh

    Another lesson learnt from you. Thank you Janis

  • Janis Zroback replied

    You’re very welcome Vicky…I’m glad you found it helpful

  • Alison Pearce

    Alison Pearce

    Thank you for sharing such a wonderful article!!

  • Janis Zroback replied

    You are very welcome Alison..

Add your comment

You need to login or signup to add your comment to this work.