As I work in IT, I’m completely comfortable with computer technology. As such, it’s hardly surprising that I jumped into photography by buying a digital camera. At the time it was just my latest tech toy but this turned out to be one that stuck. I used to go to gigs and take bad photos with my little digital camera and then when I got home I would crop and tweak mercilessly on the computer to make it look like I was a decent photographer.
I don’t do that anymore. I find it painful enough to go through a shoot of hundreds of shots (one long day I shot 1350 images) just to pull out the good stuff. I’ve no interest in then wasting more time individually editing the good images I found. If I’m going to spend time on my photography, I’d much rather be doing that with a camera in my hand and my finger on the shutter button.
So these days I’m pretty brutal. If a good image has some small flaw, it often ends up in my pile of discarded images. Most of the flaws I see were avoidable when I was shooting so I prefer to just mutter some swear words under my breath and vow to avoid that mistake in future. Maybe it sounds brutal but when I get an image exactly right, the buzz I get from that is what keeps me shooting.
Here on Redbubble there are many Photoshoppers. Some are gurus who can make an image zing with a few invisible tweaks. Some are masterful at creating fascinating collages from a few simple raw elements. On the flipside, we have those who simply can’t resist Photoshop-ing – they take a decent image and tweak it, then tweak it some more, and then some more, and then when I look at the final image, all I can see is all of the Photoshop-ing. You know the ones: simple landscapes glowing like they’re neon-lit. The effects overpower the simplicity of the original image and it ends up feeling cheap, as if the photographer couldn’t simply trust their skills with the camera. A great photo is simply that: a great photo. It doesn’t need anything else so please, stop it. If your photo isn’t interesting without Photoshop then it probably isn’t interesting at all. Our goal shouldn’t be nice images: we should always be striving for interesting images. Those are the images we remember.
This long rambling brings me to this group, perhaps my new spiritual home on Redbubble:
As-is groupRaw images, direct from the camera – that’s my kinda group. So far I’ve only dropped a few of my images in there but right now, I am completely chuffed to say 3 of the 12 images featured there are mine. I look forward to spending a lot more time with this group, sharing what I do and being in awe of what others can do with just a camera.
midzing
I appreciate your thoughts David. I think its pretty brutal to say ‘stop it’, especially when this is an arts site,,and not just a purist photography site,,,,everyone has different levels of experience and skills in photography and photoshop, and thats why I love this site,,, it brings about diversity and also creativity…I am glad you have found a group that you feel comfortable in,,,(just get ready for the hundred or so bubblemails!!!).. You also maybe interested in the Fine Art of photography, where by no or very little alterations are allowed, it is also the hardest group to get your work on, as they are only looking for the best,,,,,
david gilliver:
I should make the distinction that I’m not completely anti-Photoshop – I just hate it when excessive processing overwhelms an otherwise charming image. On the flip side, I recently saw a very boring image zapped with a Photoshop plug-in so that it ended up looking like… a boring image zapped by a Photoshop plug-in. I know I’ve been guilty of taking a decent image, editing it and then thinking I ended up with an image that looked worse than when I started. Photoshop is a tool, not a rule.
Of course, each to their own. I guess I’m just stating my philosophy…
midzing
I do agree with you David,,,,photoshop is a tool not a rule, but my beef is (and it isnt your journal entry, but many others, which are often down right rude, regarding others work.) There is always going to be the debate with the purist and the creativity side of photography, and its always an interesting debate,,,but as long as each side can respect (and I am in no way saying you dont respect) each others point of view, then its a healthy debate to have…..I personally love creating in photoshop, but I also love “capturing that perfect” shot as well…. I love both sides!! ( I am nuts!! lol)
TimChuma
Also this may help for large photo shoots
I basically only do an unsharp mask for 95% of my images (probably could get away without that.)