On Creating: Looking at the Stars From the Black Sky
Are the stars cold and distant, or infinitely beautiful and inspiring? Both, I reckon, but usually only one of the two aspects is appreciated at any given point in time, depending on one’s attitude and state of mind.
I don’t know that fear and creation are often to be found independent of each other. I used to think that most people just got on with it and made things happen without pain, and there certainly must be people out there who do it time and again with a minimum of fuss. It’s too easy to say that the act of creativity is always dogged by fear, but perhaps it’s not a stretch to say that creating and a feeling of terror often go hand in hand.
Is it the potential that scares us? The blank canvas, the computer screen with the cursor flashing in a sea of snowy nothingness, or the shadowy tangle of intense impressions and apprehensions, each of which blazed vividly in our minds for a moment in the past, which surely hold meaning that ought to be done justice and given voice to?
Is it the imminent expectation of failing to meet our highest hopes, anticipation of the frustration that meets us when we can’t physically realise what we see in our unconstrained imaginations? The ridiculousness of actually daring to think that what we feel and have to say is of the least importance?
Perhaps it’s the fact we can’t control it. Where does it come from, and how does it come to be that after a stretch of time we’ll have brought into existence something that at the beginning we had barely begun to conceive of, that was only a mere suggestion of what it would become? It seems to reveal itself, discovering twists and turns of its own as it spins itself out and takes form. This as yet unconceived or uncertain piece of writing or other work of art, or thing that aspires to be such, seems to come from nothingness. It can almost be like bringing a new world into existence, but is it an act of hubris to dare to do such a thing, or to think we can do so in a meaningful way? Surely not if we’re irresistibly, painfully, driven to do so… And even then, when it happens, is it even our doing?
So when we submit and immerse ourselves in the nothingness, what motivates us? The beauty of the idea we seek to explore, or an inner agitation that sees us either shrink into ourselves, or risk exploding outwards towards that distant light, hoping we don’t finish up in a black void of failure.
I’d love to hear your thoughts and feelings:
Do you find the creative process painful, perhaps particularly the prelude to creating, or is it simply fun, easy, and never too serious?
Do you only create when the pain of not creating is greater than the fear of creating?
Are you adept at telling such concerns to shut up, sweeping them out of your way or rolling over them with your creative juggernaut?
Are you, like me, a fan of tasty cheese?
Oh, and, where do you think art comes from?
Afterthought: It’s probably worth throwing into the mix that Marianne Williamson has this to say:
“Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure. It is our light, not our darkness that most frightens us…”
Comments
As a kind of postscript, since most of what I have on RB is photography, I might add that as someone who has always been in particular awe of skilfully wielded words and writers, I think I like photography so much and spend so much time on it (comparatively, rather than writing), because that something/the subject is already there. I find it so much easier to appreciate what is already in front of my eyes than to pull something out from within me and start from scratch. And I suppose it can be less ‘dangerous’ in that sense too.
Dear Georgie, I have in the past and in particular in the last year struggled with everything you have teased out here. I would like to add my thoughts here but don’t have the time right now – but I will, soon. One thing only though, I don’t really agree with you on this “so much easier to appreciate what is already in front of my eyes than pull something out from within me and start from scratch”. When you “see” one of your beautifully composed and captured abstracts, it really is an act of creation – just because the forms are there doesn’t mean everyone can “see” them. The act of “seeing” the poetry in the forms is your act of creation, your unique “eye”. It’s just like the writer working with all the existing words there are to form the sentences that make up the creative prose. What you do is not easy and the mere act of doing anything artistic or creative is “dangerous”. And it’s normal to doubt ourselves.
This is a great musing, I would like to talk mare, but I must go – hold those thoughts, Georgie. Glad you put them down. Until later.
Thanks very much for coming by and sharing your thoughts R. I think for me there’s probably one less barrier when photographing something rather than writing something, even if it’s just the illusion of not being so responsible for what is created or starting from without rather than within. And then of course, in forms of photography other than street/photojournalism/instantaneous recording of moments, there are also plenty of planned shoots where the concept first appears in the imagination and then is brought to life.
– Georgie Hart
Beautifully written and thought-provoking piece GH.
Thanks for taking the time to read it RO.
– Georgie Hart
I remember a high school teacher telling you you think too much Georgie. Whilst I didn’t agree with him at the time, now I say less negative thinking and more positive action!!…You have so much talent – you can do it all !! Beautifully written!!!
Funny, I was just thinking of him saying that not five minutes ago! Just read this which is very apt. Thanks for your comment M :)
– Georgie Hart
And, of course, your support.
– Georgie Hart
Thought proving for sure (been thinking about this post for days already) and of course very well written.
I dont know G, let me quote Vincent Van Gogh ~ “For my part I know nothing with any certainty, but the sight of the stars makes me dream.”
It is one of my fave quotes and how I feel.
(And yes I am a fan of tasty cheese:-)
Thanks so much for your input D, so glad this got you thinking – and that quote is fabulous! I shall put another tick in the ‘tasty cheese’ column too ;)
– Georgie Hart
Oh! I missed reading your insightful musings, G! Brilliant! Brilliant because you ask questions I’ve feared exploring. And written beautifully, crafting compelling questions smoothly.
Do you find writing and photography that different? From fears of hubris to bursting with the need to create—well, I must read this again. Perhaps you’d allow me to post a link to this from my website?
Brave woman, to explore the inner workings.
Thank you for taking the time to read this and share your thoughts Jan, I’d be honoured if you were to link to it from your website!
Not much bravery involved in writing this (another case of getting to the point where it was easier to write than not to write and continue to go around in purely mental circles).
– Georgie Hart
If I were to use categories in my situation you might have to throw me in with this, however, I am a fan of tasty cheese too Georgie.“Do you only create when the pain of not creating is greater than the fear of creating?” I get edgy when the creative juices are not in top gear.
You have a great writers streak G, first noticed it from your comments.
BB
Thanks so much for dropping by and weighing in Barbara, I’m always fascinated to hear the thoughts of others on these subjects. Glad to meet another tasty cheese fan also ;)
– Georgie Hart
Oh, and while in the process of creating, whether zapped by a sudden epiphany or motivated by discomfort, I feel nothing but the process. When done, however, comes doubt. Reveal to others? Reveal quickly and then delete? The inevitable comparisons, zeal for perfection, and, as you note, the lack of control — in creating and in the results and moving past the process to something new.
Obviously, I haven’t a clue. But this I know: we do feed our Labs cheese from a squeeze can — motivates them to chew their meds when necessary.
Cheese is a many-splendored thing!
As for the serious stuff, if all you’re feeling whilst creating is the process that must make the whole thing honest and true, I think.
Yes the inevitable comparisons are dangerous, after a while it’s hard to separate what you’ve seen before, pondered, dreamt, overheard or truly conceived as (relatively) original. And if you don’t know where it came from, or even if you do, where does it stand against everything that has already been made, not to mention in comparison to the envisaged form you held in your mind…? What about when you look back at this thing from a point in the future when you have more experience, and can see only flaws? Hmm, what if other people see unintentional parallels to the work of others…what if they (shudder) don’t care at all, or think the creation is a complete waste of space… what if the moon is made of cheese?
Mmm, cheese.
Yes it’s worth creating anyway, as whatever the outcome the experience is informative. And it’s worth sharing anyway, as sometimes others see and reveal delightful things I’ve missed, plus sometimes it just makes them glad to see it – and that’s really rewarding.
– Georgie Hart
Do you only create when the pain of not creating is greater than the fear of creating?
this is such a good question …. and I never actually asked myself like this and yet the answer is : YES – that’s what it is about for me : when the pain of not creating is greater than the fear of creating
… interesting is how this has changed over the years : there used to be perhaps years between those painful “contractions” delivering some actual “materialised” creative output (actual painting I mean) …… (otherwise – creativity ended up being masked by all kinds of “other” ways NOT counted for creativity as such …from cooking to sewing and room decorating etc) … now it is not years but weeks ….. I observed that “giving myself permission” to create despite all (which seems quite reckless at times) has made me a lot happier and stronger ‘being’ on the inside ….. still only “growing those wings” stage but feels better and better with each smallest accomplishment ……….
Oh Anna thank you so much for coming by and leaving your words.
I love your concept of the painful contractions preceding the delivery of artistic creations, such a great way to put it!
I also love the line in your profile where you say you “initiate a dialogue to find out something that might have been asking to be ‘materialised’ into an ‘image’”, as that suggests the something is waiting somewhere for you and knows what it needs to be.
I can relate to the creative procrastination you mention, and I’m so glad that you are creating more frequently now (perhaps it’s more reckless not to create when you have such ability and need?) and that creating art more often is making you stronger and happier!
– Georgie Hart
my greatest fears are that I will a- fade into obscurity for being too average and b- being noticed.
Oh Sonja you are not alone there, but few have the self awareness and courage to voice such fears! Thank you so much for stopping by and challenging fear b.
– Georgie Hart