Malaysian Skin
An article about Asia’s obsession with fairness
I sent this to theSun Newspaper in Malaysia which claims to be “telling it as it is” and got a reply from the editor.
Dear Colin,
I don’t think I’ll be able to use the article on skin whiteners. It would
look odd (hypocritical) since theSun may have been guilty of accepting
ads on such products.
regards
chong cheng hai
theSun
This isn’t telling it as it is!
Malaysian Skin belongs to the following groups:
Complex Simplicity of Art, ! $$☻The Christmas Shop (Get Art Promoted)☺ !, ! 100% !, "Poetry and Beautiful Women" , ***♂♥♥QUORN♥♥♀, All Around the Styles, All Out Emotion, All Things Poetic, Artistic, Philosophical, Amazing Asia, ART ACTION UNION - CREATIVE ACTIVISM, Avant-Garde, contrasting perceptions HELP WANTED NEED CO HOST TO RUN CHALLENGES APPLY IN THE FORUMS. THANKS, Culture Jam - Jam it up, Current Issues, Everyday Life, Everyday Women, First Things, Freedom to Shine, Friends of Bangor and North Down Camera Club, Northern Ireland, If it doesn't belong, JPG Cast-Offs, Light In The Darkness, Live, Love, Dream: May you have a Blessed Christmas Season , Multiracial Beauty, Mysteries of the Common(2 per day), Outsiders, Put Out! or Get Out!!!, Shameless Self-Promotion, That's Entertainment! (Fun & Recreation Photos), The Art of Intrigue 2/24, The Beginner's Corner (profile page must contain photography experience), The Greatest View in the World, The Healing Journey, The true beauty, The Urban Environment, The World, The World As We See It , or as we missed it., The X - Human Sentiment, Travel and Adventure, Untouchables, Who are YOU to Judge? and Woman AppreciationAsians may disagree on many things, but when it comes to skin tone there is a consensus – fair is best.
Today I went to the dermatologist for a minor procedure.
The ‘skin specialists’ office however clearly wasn’t making its money in meeting medical needs. Instead, it seemed to be meeting some would say exploiting people’s medical ‘wants’. The waiting room walls were lined with advertisements for Botox, liposuction, hair removal, and of course the ever popular skin whitening products. Almost all of the females who came in left with creams of some kind. Many had white faces, and brown bodies, a typical sight on the streets here in Malaysia. The girl cashing out in front of me bought a list of ten skin products costing her almost 400 U.S. dollars (1155 rm Malaysia). Keep in mind that the average Malaysian makes around 7000 U.S. Dollars per year.
Having lived in Malaysia for over a year I should have expected the crowds, creams and fake faces. One’s ‘skin’ is an odd enemy here. However, as reported in the New York Times’ “Glamour at a High Price in Asia “(May 1, 2006) Malaysia is not alone. This issue is Asian wide. According to one study done by Synovate in 2004, 41 percent of women in Malaysia say they use skin whitening cream. More importantly, many women are using it at dangerously high dosages (NY Times, 2006). Some of these creams (e.g. Hydroquinone) are thought to be cancerous. In addition, many illegal creams are circulating the black-market. The most effective are the cheapest and also usually the most dangerous.
Transnational corporations have their hands dirty in this business. Companies like Olay name whitening creams with fancy phrases such as ‘Glowing Radiance,’ L’Oreal markets one called ‘White Perfect’. These businesses push their products by emphasizing how one can feel ‘younger’, ‘healthier’, and more’ beautiful’. Apparently the message has gotten through.
Billboards all over Asia show white-washed models with faces so highlighted they have lost all detail. Citizens know it is Photoshop yet embrace this ideal that ‘Fair Skin’ is your friend while ‘hyper-pigmentation’ (pseudo-scientific term used by those marketing their skin lightening products) is the enemy. The media has defined the symptoms of an illusionary corporate-created disease
As reported in Thomas Fuller’s article in the New York Times, some blame this situation on white European colonizers. Their complexions were fairer and set the standard for attractiveness. Others say it is the idea that the wealthy and educated aren’t out in the sun, while the laborers are exposed to the elements. Hence, one’s skin tone is an indication of class.
The problem is all over Asia. It is not ethical business for these conglomerates to partake in the ongoing ‘white-perfect’ propaganda. If these companies really cared about their consumers they would not market themselves in such ways, let alone sell these products. It is a real shame seeing beautiful woman whose face has been scarred forever by some silly over-priced goop.
One girl I met here told me how she vied to be teased by relatives for being the darkest in the family. Sadly, she dealt with this through self harm. Today, thanks to enlightened friends and a broader education, she can see this issue from other angles. Nobody should have to feel uncomfortable in the skin they were born with.


ellcot
Some of my dearest friends are asian, so I’ve known about this issue from them. Ironically, I have fair skin and have often envied their’s. As a woman, I have never felt comfortable in my own skin – wouldn’t dare leave the house without make-up. It is a sad commentary on our appearance-based cultures. Women are raised to feel they must be beautiful (no matter what the subjective definition) and unconsciously do whatever it takes to try and fit that role. The insecurities start with family attitudes – as with the girl you mention being teased by relatives.
I’m now considered “old”, so I am no longer affected the same way. But, I will never forget all the years of feeling ugly because I didn’t have the perfect skin.
Thank you so much for writing about this issue that affects women all over the world.
Colinizing Ph... replied
great points and thanks for reading :)
Gregory John O...
I feel in love with a Malaysian women. I am glad she wasn’t driven by the colour of flesh …... wish I knew where she is….
Sally Omar
FEATURED IN MULTIRACIAL BEAUTY!!!!
AWESOME WORK!!!
sweetscent62
This subject still amazes me Colin, the idea of white skin being more beautiful. I grew up in a migrant community where I was a freak.. (my mother was Australian..and my father Latvian..both fair) and I was the only person I knew with pale skin…blue eyes and blonde hair. I was labelled as trash by the Greek, Italian,Turkish and Lebanese in the community because I looked different! So sad to be judged on ones skin pigment..even sadder that it still happens in parts of the world in the 21st century. I’m enjoying your photographs Colin.. : ) keep up the great work! Wendy x
Colinizing Ph... replied
Thanks so much for reading!
CanyonWind
My best model is Chinese , and if she ever did such a thing I wiuold drop her in a munute. Her shin is beautiful.
POP’s
bernard lacoque
Sad and important article. The problem exists same way in Africa . Multiracial Beauty is one way to stand against this. Thank you for it Sally.
PriscillaSiew
Perhaps more than an indication of social class or colonial hangover this has to do with the universal human desire for what one does not naturally have – Asians trying to be whiter, Caucasians trying to be more tanned, women all over the world starving themselves to achieve the kind of body that is natural to only 1? 2? percent of the female population. Women all over the world are faced with these kinds of social pressure and expectations right from young – it’s hard to see past what has become your reality. It would take a strong, independent-minded, discerning individual to define for herself what she wants, esp in collectivist Asia – and to be honest, how many of such people are there around? I know just a handful, out of the hundreds of women.
Colinizing Ph... replied
Thanks Priscilla… I hear everything you are saying – it is a complicated issue.