Your Question

You always start your day by beginning mine; with arms full of the accoutrements of your quirky slumber and a sleepy stagger that barges your tousled hair through our bedroom door, the one with the dent in the wood after I found my temper; you’d locked yourself inside and your Mum had been worried about the medication on the locker.
This mornings entrance was no different, other than as you jumped into the bed, poached a pillow, and then entangled your cold feet beneath my knees, you caught me looking at you with my good eye, and you asked a question that I couldn’t respond to, not because you were too young to understand, but because I wasn’t clever enough to have the answer ready, so I was flippant instead. And it has bothered me all day.

You followed it up with ’What’s the best colour Dad?’ and I told you I thought it was tangerine. You told me not to be silly and you argued for blonde. We checked the weather outside and decided that hospital surgeons would be the best at building snowmen and that the ‘cats eyes’ on roads should be solar heaters too. Then you made me promise I wouldn’t die soon. And I was flippant again.

We left the beds unmade after I saw the time and I yawned to disguise my tears when you looked to the heavens and grassed me up to Mum. We hand-danced in the car to your new favourite song and as we kissed goodbye at the gate you made me repeat my promise. I did. And then I told you not to worry, which was a stupid thing to say.

I thought of you all day as I went about my work, pretending too much or not pretending at all, so I returned to your school too early and became conscious of being a man. So I drove away again. But I didn’t know where to go.

I’m back outside the school gate now, sitting in the car to avoid the head tilt conversations with the well meaning mothers. I’m still pondering your question, the one I couldn’t answer, and I’m wondering what to say to you. I’m trying to conjure up some wisdom to nurture your wonder, fretting about being the Dad I promised I’d be but hearing your Mum remind me I would never know if I was successful, because I would never know what I prevented. So I listen to her voice on my phone and decide to do what Dad’s do best. Ignore the question and wait until you repeat it.

You startle me as you bang on my car window and rest your forehead against the glass.

‘Whatya thinking Dad?’, you ask me again.


Cathal .

Your Question by

A real question, and an answer that I need to formulate. Do you know your own answer?

Favorite

Comments

  • timbuckley
    timbuckley4 months ago

    sometimes they can look inside your head and ask you the most awkward things at the most awkward times of course men dont really have any training in talking about emotions and so the pregnant pause, the ill be back to you on that one, becomes standard issue. Love the way you finish this its like one of dem horror movies when the bastard just doesnt know when to die and pops up to send popcorn flying when you thought you could relax. nice to have you back in the bubble

  • MissInvisible
    MissInvisible4 months ago

    oh dear…this made me catch my breath….i’m not sure I would have an answer either…always so many thoughts in my head. children are amazing…their intuition so pure.

  • Donna19
    Donna194 months ago

    This was an interesting read for sure. I don’t think anyone, male or female could answer this one right off the cuff. I do think that honesty and straight forward responses are healthy ones. There is nothing wrong with explaining the idea that we can never make such a promise to anyone. We live the day we are given and love every moment with the ones we love and focus on that.

  • twistwashere
    twistwashere4 months ago

    when the answer is really needed , you will give it

  • Shani Sohn
    Shani Sohn4 months ago

    You always find the details that will change the rhythm of the reader’s heart. Thanks for the great read Cathal!

  • rjcolby
    rjcolby4 months ago

    Nope…
    A cool little story, and “the” question made me laugh…
    Seriously, I may use the question myself. Granddaughters you know. ;)

  • sandra .
    sandra .4 months ago

    Yeppers!
    Lovely Cathal…always a treat to read you
    Sandra x

  • Nestor
    Nestor4 months ago

    A beautiful piece.
    I am trying, at those ‘question without notice’ moments, to slow down instead of panic. I like what someone said the Irish do(?) play for time by asking the questions back…."Would it be that you are asking……’
    But I also thought I could try, ‘I need to think about that, it’s a good question.’ There’s trying to be wise, and there is hoping dearly that some intuitive wisdom is somewhere buried beneath ready to rise when we stop trying so hard. Like Mum said, you never know what you prevented.

    What a lovely piece. The consciousness of being a man hanging around a school reality sucks. So many great observations. Hand dancing, solar cats eyes and pillow poaching.

  • Lisa Baumeler
    Lisa Baumeler3 months ago

    Oh, what I wouldn’t give for five minutes wandering around the hallways of your mind…. Another fabulous read C. I hope you are enjoying your writing workshops!