John Szarkowski once said, that photography was like poetry.
All writers use the same words that everyone else uses. They all use dictionaries which have the same words in them – in alphabetical order. All they have to do is put them in the right order, – that’s all there is to it!
Photography is just like that.
We all use the same “words” [compositional elements], and our “words” are readily available to all of us, in fact they are almost thrown at us, constantly.
All we as photographers have to do is to put those “words” – those compositional elements – together in the right order.
Its really quite simple.
And when we get that order right – it can be a truly sublime experience. We may not know why, it just is.
This is the struggle for all artists, not just photographers, to find that perfect composition, that perfect arrangement of parts that creates something intangible, something that is so much more than just the sum of its parts.
Ansel Adams once said that when he took a photograph, he was trying to convey what he felt at that moment in time, to create something that actually was not there, to create from within and not simply to take from the external.
To understand this a bit better…
There are soooo many photographs of Yosemite Valley online today. Probably millions of the damned things. Each photographer, myself included, used exactly the same “words” – the same compositional elements that Ansel Adams used. Yet 99.99% of the photographs of Yosemite are not even close to the incredible artistic beauty of Ansel’s work.
Why?
Because Ansel was not simply photographing a thing, he was always striving to convey his emotions at that point in time.
The rest of us see the Valley for the first time and we go “oooh, pretty, I think I will take a shot of that” – and that lack of regard for the true “art” behind photography is what dooms our images to mediocrity.
The true art of photography is not composition, or subject, or lighting, or processing, the true art of photography lies in the ability to communicate to another person our inner-most feelings through a visual medium.
And if we are really really lucky, we might manage to do exactly that a handfull of times in our lives.
And that is the struggle of the artist – the never ending search for that perfect moment, that perfect blend of elements, – the right “words” in the right order that transcends mere shape and form and speaks to the soul of the other person in ways that even they can not clearly explain.
That is our goal, but it certainly isn’t where we start.
We all start off making crap art. We make the art because of the need to express ourselves. Sure we might “just like taking pictures” – but underneath that, somewhere is our need to communicate. Its just that we don’t know it at that time.
So we take pictures of stuff, some of it is ok, most of it is rubbish, but we stick with it.
What we are doing in our early artistic years, is learning to “speak”, learning our “words”, – learning what works and what does not. Often our work is derivative because we mimic what we see around us, and even more often it is incredibly naive.
This is normal and natural. Its is the same for EVERYBODY.
Even Ansel Adams early work was shit.
The thing to understand is that making art is not a static process. No-one makes only good art. We try, we fail, we try again, we learn, we fail, we have a win, and then we fail again.
This is how life is.
As an artist you may never actually achieve that one great photograph. You may spend your whole life in search of it and never get it.
But being an artist is not about being perfect, but rather the struggle to be perfect.
I have been taking photographs for nearly 15 years now, and I am only now just beginning to really like the art that I produce, yet I am not satisfied with it. I know I can do better.
Because now after 15 years I know what it is that sets the great images apart from the tidal wave of mediocrity – it is the intent on the part of the photographer to communicate their feelings to the viewer.
But I didn’t know this 15 years ago. No-one does when they start – and that is because you have to learn it before you can know it. You have to grow as both a person and an artist.
It is this knowledge that is important for young artists to grasp. That the growth of the artist in each of us is the important thing, not the start point or the end point, but the constant progress,
As you grow as a person, so you grow as an artist. Never stop learning, never stop consuming everything you can about art. The more you learn the more you evolve, the closer you get to making that one perfect image.
And maybe, just maybe one day you will make that photograph.
Maybe.
Graeme Voigt
Arrr… very well written.
A great read. So very true…
BYRON:
THank you Graeme!
robpixaday
Bravo!!
Words of wisdom. thank you for sharing this!
BYRON:
Thanx Robin.
I try my best.
ThePhotoMaestro
This is really good. I know that some of my work feels better when I get that emotional connection as I take a picture. Other times, I feel like it’s almost there but I’m annoyed that I can’t quite get it. You know?
BYRON:
That’s the problem PhotoMaestro – we may spend the rest of our lives never quite getting that perfect photo. But we have to keep trying, always getting that little bit closer.
DragonFlyer
You have, Byron, in your typical style, cut right to the core of the issue.
Perfectly clearly and well written – and exactly right and true.
K x
BYRON:
Thanx Kallena. I got a new keyboard for my computer yesterday, and I just felt like writing some stuff.
Miron Abramovici
You got it right!
BYRON:
Thank you Miron!
dasSuiGeneris
Nice commentary! This exudes experience and ingrained beliefs. This is excellent reading BYRON!
BYRON:
Thnax SuiGeneris, I am glad you liked it.
Dinni H
great inspiring reading Byron
BYRON:
Thank you Dinni. I just felt like writing some stuff yesterday with my new keyboard.
SRana
yep, thanks Bryon for this, very inspiring but pratising for 15 years to just get there does sound quite like climing an Everest.
BYRON:
Its like that SRana, for everyone.
Its not so much practicing for 15 years, as it is growing as an artist for 15 years… and I still have maybe another 30 years to go.
A lot of new photographers seem to get frustrated that their work is not getting great reviews, – I think they need to understand that it takes a looooong time before your work really reaches a consistantly good standard.
Sure, some people are naturally gifted, but that is very very rare.
For the rest of us it is a lifelong journey of learning and growing both as a person and as an artist.
rocamiadesign
Very well spoken, Bryon! You’ve explained the source of my frustration, when I think I’ve finally achieved perfection with an image until I look at it the next day and spot all my mistakes. However, this artistic process is like sex. It may take years of practice to reach our goal, but the practice is still fun.
BYRON:
No, the artistic process is not like sex… at least I never got tied-up and spanked while taking photos heh heh heh!
Rachel Davison
So true – and so well articulated – it’s great to be reminded of this, to step back, slow down and get perspective in this fast impatient world. You nailed it… thanks for inspiring me, Byron!
BYRON:
Thank you for your kind words Rachel.
PhotoMairo
Your words touched my soul … thanks so much … and let me tell you that I enjoy the way of growing, with all fail and win, enjoy hoping for that one damn good photo :)
BYRON:
Wow, what a lovely thing to say. I am so glad that you have got so much from this.
DelitefulDee
Thanks for leading me over here to read this. When you said “being an artist is not about being perfect, but rather the struggle to be perfect,” really is the what being an artist is all about, I couldn’t agree more. I’ve said the same thing countless times when I am asked if I ‘destest the end result so much, why do I keep trying?’ Because that’s what I thought the whole point of art was about.
Martin Dingli 8 days ago
Excellent!